14 Creepiest Documentaries That’ll Make You Want to Sleep with the Lights On

5. Albert Fish: In Sin He Found Salvation

Albert Fish was a child molester and cannibal who was active during the mid-1920s. A deeply religious man, Fish’s killings were inspired by fearful passages from the Bible and ultimately took on a sacrificial bent. John Borowski’s haunting documentary chronicles the life of this real life monster.