14 Creepiest Documentaries That’ll Make You Want to Sleep with the Lights On

4. There’s Something Wrong With Aunt Diane

In 2009, it looked like 36-year-old Diane Schuler had it all. She was a seemingly content mother and wife living in Westchester, New York. Then, on July 26, while driving her daughter and three nieces around town, she collided head on with an SUV. The accident killed Schuler, her daughter, all three nieces, and the three people in the SUV. This documentary delves into Schuler’s life in an attempt to uncover how someone who seemed so together could unravel so completely and with such disastrous results.